shrooms.zone

Mushrooms, against the public record

Updated

Birch polypore

Fomitopsis betulina · also razor strop fungus

A pale hoof on dead birch. It was found in the pouch of the 5,300-year-old Iceman, which is the most-repeated claim about it and the one worth reading carefully.

Laboratory work — its best-evidenced use is wound healing

Birch polypore, Fomitopsis betulina, photographed in Cranston, RI, US
Fomitopsis betulina, Cranston, RI, US. Photograph by Deana Tempest Thomas, CC BY, via iNaturalist — the observation

Nobody has run a trial of it in people that reached a public register, and no randomised trial of it has been indexed. Everything below is laboratory work, where it grows, and what people report.


What it is taken for

One tile per use. The line under each is how far the evidence for that use actually got, counted rather than argued.


What it has been tried for, and how far that has got

One row per use. The label is counted rather than argued — it is set by how many randomised trials and posted results exist for that use, and nothing else. How that is worked out.

UseHow far it has gotTrialsWith a resultRandomised, publishedReviewsCommonly taken for it
Gut and microbiomeLaboratory work0000yes
InflammationLaboratory work0000yes
Wound healingLaboratory work0000yes

Commonly taken for gut and microbiome, inflammation, wound healing. The work there is still laboratory and animal work — often a great deal of it — and the step into a trial in people has not been taken yet.


The compounds the research names

Formula and mass from PubChem. Naming a compound is not a claim that it does anything in a person.

betulinic acid

C30H48O3

456.7 g/mol · PubChem CID 64971


What it looks like in the field

Research-grade observations, each by a different photographer. Every one links to the record it came from.

Birch polypore, Fomitopsis betulina
Воскресенский р-н, Московская обл., Россия, snaily_naily · CC BY
Birch polypore, Fomitopsis betulina
305 Jackson Rd, Medford, NJ, US, Daniel Atha · CC0

In the kitchen

What it tastes like

Bitter, and tough as cork.

How it is cooked

Not food. Thin slices are steeped as a tea; the dried flesh has a long history as a strop for razors and as tinder.


Where it has been recorded, and when it fruits

178,738 verified occurrence records with coordinates, from GBIF. This is where people have recorded it, which follows where recorders live as much as where the fungus grows — read the shape, not the ranking.

Records by country

Netherlands58,639
United Kingdom31,112
Sweden18,234
United States13,377
Germany9,497
Canada7,461
Denmark7,172
Norway6,622
Finland5,078
Belgium4,605
France3,925
Russia3,847

Records by month

JFMAMJJASOND

Most records fall in Oct. Northern-hemisphere recorders dominate the dataset, so a southern population would not show here.

iNaturalist separately holds 57,240 research-grade observations of it.


What has been reported going wrong

No voluntary adverse-event report to the US Food and Drug Administration names a product by this name. That is an absence of reports, not a demonstration of safety: these are the products least likely to be reported on, because nobody is required to.

Every report, every species